In a Probate Sale, Your Accepted Offer Is Only the Opening Bid

Ninety percent. That is the floor on a court confirmed probate sale in California, and it is ninety percent of a number you had no part in choosing.

Probate Code section 10309 says a private sale cannot be confirmed for less than 90 percent of the appraised value, and that the appraisal has to have been made within one year before the confirmation hearing, with a valuation date inside that same year. The appraisal comes from a probate referee. Under section 8902 the personal representative appraises the cash, and the referee appraises everything else, which means the house. Not you. Not the CMA you spent a Saturday on.

So the first move on a probate listing is not a price opinion. It is a document request.

Get the Inventory and Appraisal before you say a number out loud

Ask for the filed Inventory and Appraisal and read two things: the appraised value, and the valuation date. A figure set during a slow stretch is a gift to your buyer pool. A figure set at the top of a run can strand the listing above where the market is willing to go. The court can order a reappraisal if the property was never appraised, if the appraisal or its valuation date is more than a year old, or if the court decides the figure is too high or too low. That last clause is the one to remember, because it means a bad number is an argument you can have, not a wall you hit.

Ask what authority the administrator actually has

Under the Independent Administration of Estates Act, an administrator with full authority can sell without the court confirming it. With limited authority, court supervision applies, confirmation has to happen before title passes, and the report of sale and the petition for confirmation get filed within 30 days after the sale. Two very different marketing jobs wearing the same word.

Either way, a notice of proposed action goes to the people with an interest, and Los Angeles Superior Court Rule 4.58(a) requires that notice to spell out the material terms of the transaction, sales price included. Your pricing will be read, in writing, by beneficiaries who did not hire you and may not be in a generous mood. Price it like it is going to be cross examined.

In a confirmation sale, the accepted offer is the opening bid

This is the part most agents get wrong, and it is the part with actual money in it.

At the confirmation hearing, anyone can overbid. The first overbid has to exceed the accepted offer by 10 percent of the first $10,000 plus 5 percent of the balance. On a $1,200,000 offer, that is $1,000 plus $59,500, so the first competing bid opens at $1,260,500. Bids are counted gross, before brokerage fees. If more than one is acceptable, the court takes the highest.

Which means your marketing does not stop at acceptance. It changes audience.

Keep the listing visible. Keep showing it. Keep a written list of the second and third place buyers and their agents, and send them a one page explanation of how an overbid works: the hearing date, the opening number, the cashier's check they need to walk in with. Then follow up like it is a live listing, because it is. This is the only kind of deal in your career where losing the first offer is a feature.

The commission is capped, so spend the marketing budget on purpose

Los Angeles Superior Court Rule 4.39(d) says the court will not permit a commission to an agent, broker or auctioneer above five percent on improved real property, with up to ten percent allowed on raw land, and anything beyond that only in exceptional circumstances.

There is no making it up later. Decide the photography, video, print and signage budget before you take the listing, not after you have promised the family a campaign. I run a marketing agency and I will happily take your money, and I would still rather you know the ceiling going in than find it at the confirmation hearing.

A trust sale is not a probate sale, and it is not disclosure free either

A successor trustee holding a power of sale usually sells like any other seller. No referee floor, no overbid, no hearing, no filing clock. Faster, quieter, far easier to market conventionally.

Two cautions. Los Angeles Superior Court Rule 4.107 points trust real property sales at Probate Code section 10300 and following, including publication of a notice of intention to sell, unless an exception applies, such as the trust itself granting the power of sale. Read the trust before you promise anybody a three week escrow.

Then the disclosure question. Civil Code 1102.2(b) exempts sales ordered by a probate court from the Transfer Disclosure Statement. Subsection (d) exempts sales by a fiduciary in the course of administering a trust or a decedent's estate. And here is the exception inside the exception, which catches people every year: if the trustee is a natural person serving as trustee of a revocable trust, and that person was a former owner of the property or occupied it within the preceding year, the exemption does not apply. The daughter who lived in her mother's house and is now the successor trustee is handing over a TDS.

Being exempt from a form was never the same as being allowed to stay quiet. Known material facts get disclosed either way.

What to do this week

Pull the Letters and the Inventory and Appraisal on any probate listing you are chasing, and read the authority line before you build a listing presentation around it. If it is a trust, ask the estate's counsel for the power of sale provision in writing. And draft the overbid handout now, while nothing is pending, so you are not writing it at ten at night the week of a hearing.

Everyone treats these listings as sad and cheap. The file is sad. The house is a house, on a street buyers already want, with a statute bolted to it. Market the house.

Plain English summary of public law, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Probate and trust procedure turns on the specific file, the authority actually granted and the current local rules, which change. Verify with your broker and the estate's counsel before relying on any of it.

Previous
Previous

The rain kit I would want in an LA house before the El Niño storms

Next
Next

Neighborhood Files: Brentwood Glen, the Pocket Most Agents Drive Past